Correct option: Option
(C)
Explanation of correct option:
Step 1: Write the values of both charges.
- As $$N$$ no. of charges are separated each with charge $$q$$, let $$n$$ be the no. of charges at the first point with $$q_1=nq$$ charge and thus another point will have $$(N-n)$$ no. of charges with charge $$q_2=(N-n)q$$.
Step 2: Apply Coulomb's law
- Electrostatic force$$(F)$$ is directly proportion to the product of charges$$(q_1q_2)$$ and inversely proportional to square of distance between them$$(r^2)$$
- $$F=k\dfrac{q_1q_2}{r^2}$$ ,,,$$(k= proportionality\ constant)$$
$$\therefore F=\dfrac{k(nq)(N-n)q}{r^2}=\dfrac{kq^2n(N-n)}{r^2}$$
Step 3:
- As the no. of charges are natural numbers, the arithmetic mean is greater than equal to the geometric mean.
$$\therefore AM \ge GM$$
Arithmetic mean is the ratio of the sum of the values to the no. of values.
$$AM=\dfrac{n+(N-n)}{2}=\dfrac{N}{2}$$
Geometric mean is the $$n^{th}$$ root of the product of the $$n$$ no. of values.
$$GM=\sqrt{n(N-n)}$$
$$\therefore \dfrac{N}{2} \ge \sqrt{n(N-n)}$$
$$\therefore \dfrac{N^2}{4}\ge n(N-n)$$
Maximum value of $$n(N-n)=\dfrac{N^2}{4}$$
$$\therefore n(N-n)=\dfrac{N^2}{4}$$
$$Nn-n^2=\dfrac{N^2}{4}$$
$$n^2-Nn+\dfrac{N^2}{4}=0$$
$$n^2-Nn=\dfrac{N^2}{4}=(n-\dfrac{N}{2})^2=0$$
$$\therefore n=\dfrac{N}{2}$$
Step 4:
- Maximum value of Force $$F_{max}=\dfrac{kq^2(\dfrac{N}{2})(N-\dfrac{N}{2})}{r^2}=\dfrac{kq^2N^2}{4r^2}$$
- The minimum value of Force (n=1) $$F_{min}=\dfrac{kq^2(1)(N-1)}{r^2}=\dfrac{kq^2(N-1)}{r^2}$$
Taking the ratio of both the calculated forces,
$$\dfrac{F_{max}}{F_{min}}=\dfrac{\dfrac{kq^2N^2}{4r^2}}{\dfrac{kq^2(N-1)}{r^2}}=\dfrac{N^2r^2}{(N-1)4r^2}=\dfrac{N^2}{4(N-1)}$$
Thus, the ratio of maximum to minimum force is $$\dfrac{N^2}{4(N-1)}$$.