Consider the disturbances at $$R_1$$ which is at distance d from A. Let the wave at $$R_1$$ because of A be $$y_A \, = \, a \, cos \, \omega t.$$ The path difference of the signal from A with that from B is $$\lambda/2$$ and hence the phase difference is $$\pi$$.
Thus, the wave at $$R_1$$ because of B is
$$y_B \, = \, a \, cos \, (\omega t \, - \, \pi) \, = \, -4 \, cos \, \omega t.$$
The path difference of the single from C with that from A is $$\lambda$$ and hence, the phase difference is $$2\pi$$.
Thus, the wave at $$R_1$$ because of C is $$y_c \, = \, a \, cos \, \omega t$$.
The path difference between the signals from from D with that of A is
$$P \, = \, R_1D \, - \, R_1A \, = \, \sqrt{(R_1B)^2 \, + \, (BD)^2} \, - \, (R_1B \, - \, AB)$$
$$\sqrt{d^2 \, + \, \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{2} \right )^2} \, -(d \, - \, \lambda/2) \, = \, d \, \left(1 \, + \, \dfrac{\lambda^2}{4d^2} \right )^{1/2} \, -d \, + \, \dfrac{\lambda}{2}$$
$$d \left(1 \, + \, \dfrac{\lambda^2}{8d^2} \right ) \, -d \, + \, \frac{\lambda}{2} \, = \, \dfrac{\lambda^2}{8d} \, + \, \dfrac{\lambda}{2}$$
If d > > $$\lambda$$, the path difference $$- \, \dfrac{\lambda}{2}$$ and hence the phase difference is $$\pi$$.
$$\therefore \, y_D \, = \, -a \, cos \, \omega t.$$
Thus, the single picked up at $$R_1$$ is
$$y \, = \, y_A \, + \, y_B \, + \, y_C \, + \, y_D \, = \, 0$$
Let the signal picked up at $$R_2$$ from B be $$y_B \, = \, a_1 \, cos \, \omega t.$$
The path difference between signal at D and that at B is $$\lambda/2$$
$$\therefore \, y'_D \, = \, -a_1 \, cos \, \omega t$$
The path difference between signal at A and B is
$$\sqrt{(d)^2 \, + \, \left(\dfrac{\lambda}{2} \right)^2} \, -d \, = \, d\left(1 \, + \, \dfrac{\lambda^2}{4d^2} \right )^{1/2} \, -d \, = \, \dfrac{\lambda^2}{8d}$$
$$\therefore$$ The phase difference is
$$\dfrac{2\pi}{\lambda} \cdot \dfrac{\lambda^2}{8d} \, = \, \dfrac{\pi \lambda}{4d} \, = \, \phi \, ~ \, 0.$$
Hence, $$y_A \, = \, a_1 \, cos \, (\omega t \, ~ \, \phi)$$
similarly, $$y'_C \, = \, a_1 \, cos \, (\omega t \, - \, \phi)$$
$$\therefore$$ Signal picked up by $$R_2$$ is
$$y'_A \, + \, y'_B \, + \, y'_C \, + \, y'_D \, = \, y' \, = \, 2a \, cos \, (\omega t \, ~ \, \phi)$$
$$[\because \, y'_B \, + \, y'_D \, = \, 0]$$
$$\therefore \, |y|^2 \, = \, 4a^2_1 \, cos^2 \, (\omega t \, - \, \phi)$$
$$\therefore \, <I> \, = \, 2a^2_1$$
Thus $$R_2$$ picks up the large signal.