Concept:
Since the bars are in parallel:
\({\delta _{ad1}} + {\delta _{th1}} = {\delta _{ad2}} + {\delta _{th2}}\)
∴ \({\delta _{th1}} - {\delta _{th2}} = {\delta _{ad1}} - {\delta _{ad2}}\)
where, δth1 and δth2 are the change in the length of copper bar and steel bar respectively due to thermal stress.
And δad1 and δad2 are the change in length due to axial stress in Cu bar and steel bar respectively.
The deformation of the bar is given as,
αcLcT - αsLsT = \(\frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_c}{{\rm{L}}_c}}}{{{{\rm{E}}_c}}} + \frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_s}{{\rm{L}}_s}}}{{{{\rm{E}}_s}}}\) …(1)
Calculation:
Given:
Lc = Ls = 1 m, T = 80, Ec = 1 × 105 N/mm2, Es = 2 × 105 N/mm2
Assuming coefficient of thermal expansion ,
αc = 16 × 10-6/˚C, αs = 12 × 10-6/˚C
Put in equation (1),
80 × (16 – 12)× 10-6 = \(\frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_c}}}{{1 × {{10}^{ - 5}}}} + \frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_s}}}{{2 × {{10}^{ - 5}}}}\)
2σc + σs = 64 … (2)
Also since The stress in the bar is \(\sigma=\frac{P}{A}\)
\(\frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_{\rm{c}}}}}{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_{\rm{s}}}}} = \frac{{{{\rm{A}}_{\rm{s}}}}}{{{{\rm{A}}_{\rm{c}}}}}\)......(Here, P is the same for both bars)
\(\frac{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_c}}}{{{{\rm{\sigma }}_s}}} = \frac{{600}}{{200}} = 3\)
σc = 3σs …(3)
Solving (2) and (3), we get
σs = 9.14 MPa (Tensile)
σc = 27.42 MPa (compressive)
Note:
Since the coefficient of thermal expansion not mentioned answer differs from the option. But as we know Copper tube has a greater coefficient of thermal expansion so compressive stress will be developed and steel having a lesser coefficient of thermal expansion will have tensile stresses developed.