Key Concept
The oxidation of a primary alcohol (1°) can be stopped at the aldehyde stage only if water is rigorously excluded from the reaction medium. Water facilitates the hydration of the aldehyde to a gem-diol, which is then easily oxidized further to a carboxylic acid (R–COOH). Among the common Cr(VI) reagents, CrO₃ in an anhydrous medium (used in Collins reagent, PCC, etc.) is specifically designed for this purpose. In contrast, aqueous Cr(VI) or strong oxidants like Mn(VII) inevitably lead to over-oxidation to the carboxylic acid.
Step-by-step Analysis of the Options
A. KMnO4 / H⁺ (acidic)
Potassium permanganate (KMnO4) is a very powerful oxidizing agent, especially in an acidic medium (reduction potential E° ≈ +1.51 V). It rapidly oxidizes a primary alcohol first to an aldehyde and then immediately to a carboxylic acid. Over-oxidation is unavoidable.
R–CH₂OH → [R–CHO] → R–COOH
Therefore, this option is not suitable.
B. CrO3 in anhydrous medium
Chromium trioxide (CrO3) is a Cr(VI) oxidizing agent. When used in an anhydrous (water-free) environment, it selectively oxidizes primary alcohols to aldehydes. The absence of water prevents the formation of the gem-diol hydrate, thus halting the oxidation at the aldehyde stage.
R–CH₂OH + CrO3 (anhydrous) → R–CHO
Common laboratory reagents based on this principle include:
- PCC (Pyridinium chlorochromate) in CH₂Cl₂
- Collins reagent (CrO3·2Py) in CH₂Cl₂
These are standard methods taught for this specific conversion. Therefore, this is the correct choice.
C. Conc. H2SO4
Concentrated sulfuric acid is a strong dehydrating agent, not an oxidizing agent for alcohols. It promotes elimination reactions, leading to the formation of alkenes (at ~170 °C) or ethers (at ~140 °C). It does not perform the required oxidation.
D. LiAlH4
Lithium aluminium hydride (LiAlH4) is a powerful reducing agent. It performs the reverse reaction, reducing carbonyl compounds (like aldehydes and ketones) and carboxylic acids to alcohols. It is not an oxidizing agent.
Conclusion
Only CrO3 in an anhydrous medium (option B) is the correct reagent to oxidize a primary alcohol to an aldehyde without further oxidation to a carboxylic acid.